Tagged with captaincy

And So The Succession Begins

On the face of it, there’s nothing significant about Ricky Ponting giving up playing international T20 cricket. After all, he couldn’t be arsed showing up for the first 4 ODIs in England (by which time his side will probably have an unassailable lead anyway), so why wear himself out on hit-and-giggle cricket?

But think about it. This is the first sign that the old order is changing, and it might be to Australia’s advantage. Since the Chappell/Yallop/Hughes era of Packer-inspired confusion, Australia have liked to have their captaincy succession clearly set out well in advance. The only one in line to take over from Border was Taylor and the only one in line to replace Taylor was Waugh.

Ironically, the last time things were anything less than clear cut was when both Warne and Gilchrist blotted their copybooks and let Punter himself in.

But look at the list of names above. None of them are as in love with the limelight as Michael Clarke is. And how the hell can anyone gain respect as a captain when the whole world knows them as ‘Pup’?

On the other hand, of the list above, only three players have improved their overall international record as captain. Chappell and Border are two of them, but the other one is Clarke.

Which makes you wonder if the time for the Ponting style of captain, the scowling, emotionless (unless faced with Gary Pratt) leader, is at an end. There’s been no sign of Clarke being a tactical genius, but the way he behaves in the field, both admonishing and laughing at himself, might be the way forward for this new generation of Aussie cricketers. After all, Ponting hardly got the best out of them or himself this summer. Might it be time for him to hand over the reins altogether?

Tagged , , ,

Ponting Vs Strauss: who is the smartest guy in the special needs class

Ricky’s flaws are there for all of us to see.

Quick to anger, punchy, get’s a little lost, doesn’t always admit to mistakes, and has the tendency to go with the wrong bowler.

But what about Andrew?

Sure he is the smoother package, I saw him do a press conference at Lord’s today and he is smooth, but what about on the field.

On day 4 he never really turned up, he has a sick reliance on Stuart Broad, overbowled Freddie in the scheme of things, uses nightwatchman for tailenders, and can’t declare.

It is slim pickings.

Ricky’s failings are more obvious, but Andrew’s are there for most people to see.

They do have their positives offcourse.

Ponting gets the most out of his players, is a definite leader, is learning how to get wickets on slow flat pitches, reads his bowlers well, wants to win more than anyone out on the ground and bats very well as captain.

Strauss is a composed guy, has handled the new transition very well, is well liked by the players, says the right things, gives the players responsibility, and really wants the job.

I think Ponting out captained Strauss in the first test.

Yes he made some mistakes in the last session, but I think mistake for mistake Strauss had him covered.

Let us see how test number 2 pans out.

Tagged , , , , ,
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 8,531 other followers