wunderkind to skipper

Rick (y) Ponting is a weird man.

After inheriting one of the greatest test teams of all time, he seemed a lot more worried about ruining their record than actually winning when he first got the job.

Then he had several melt downs against the English. Coupled with the fact McGrath fell over and Martyn was clearly sleeping with several daughters of umpires, he lost that series.

More often than not Ponting captained via the committee system. He never seemed to make any decisions that weren’t in consultation with, Lehmann, Hussey, Gilchrist, or Warne.

No one was harsher on him than me. Except possibly my dad, whose favourite phrase is “he’s not a captains @sshole”.

However In recent times Ponting has actually looked like a captain, a real one.

My belief is that losing Warne and McGrath, is the best thing that can happen to him as a captrain.

Rick (y) is not a deep thinker. He has never had to be, he was a child prodigy who became a legend. Talented people don’t think as much as the non talented, why should they.

Suddenly losing over a 1000 wickets, he has to think. He can’t captain on autopilot anymore. For him it’s not natural to think about cricket.

He doesn’t need to train as hard as Justin Langer, he doesn’t need to think about batting like Nasser Hussain, and he doesn’t need to invent wickets like Stephen Fleming did.

He is the boy wonder who made captain of an amazing cricket side, which is quite different to the men who preceded him.

Steve Waugh was a historian, who believed that pace bowlers could win any match, and if not I’ll bring that blonde guy on. This is the man that liked bowling first, with the second greatest leg spinner of all time on his side. He was born talented, but not Ponting like.

Mark Taylor was a strategic captain, who didn’t like the game to get out of hand. He would use spinners early, part timers all the time and was constantly thinking of new fields that would disrupt the batsmen. As a batsman he was an average opening batsmen who kept himself in his side because of his captaining.

Allan Border was old school. He liked to abuse his players, he wanted tough cricketers, and if you weren’t up to it, you were told you weren’t up to it. He was the perfect Vice Captain. As a batsman he was talented, but he fought for everything that came to him.

Each of these captains got a better side than their predecessor. But Ponting is the man who was given the gold star treatment. He came into a team that was already World champions, he didn’t have to fight the West Indies like the others did.

He is defined like Border and Steve Waugh by winning. His whole life is about winning, about being the best, like Jordan and Hitler before him. Captaincy is the one thing he is not the best at, but you can see how bad he wants that as well.

Ponting is a clicky sort of guy, Dizzy Gillespie and Cameron White have found out as much. If you’re his friend he will drag you along until your ready like Symonds, or if your not one of his favourites you won’t be given any time to shine.

His best friend in the team was Damien Martyn that tells you a lot about him. When I flew with the Aussie team, I noticed that in general the team grouped together, but Martyn and Ponting were separate, speaking in hushed tones.

I only noticed all this cause I was perving on Mrs Ponting.

The two things I noticed about his captaincy in the first test were, that he actually enforced the follow on. Vvs Laxman wasn’t playing, but neither were the two greatest bowlers of the last ten years.

The second was the way he used Symonds with the ball. He used him in a proactive way. In the past Symonds was thrown the ball because it seemed like the right thing to do, however this time he was thrown the ball as an attacking tactic.

It worked, twice.

Enforcing the follow on worked as well. Finally Ponting is learning to trust his instincts. He’ll need to, this side is probably never going to be as good as it was before.

It needs the captain to step up.

The signs are good, the best captains are born with strategic knowledge and a feel for the game. For the rest of us, we need to learn as we go.

Tagged , , , ,

9 thoughts on “wunderkind to skipper

  1. Andrew Mosey says:

    When I first read the title of this story I suspected that Clarke had been handed the reigns for Hobart. Richie mentioned that MC might get a shot this year, and I can’t see why not.. seems a good idea to groom the annointed next captain, as he doesn’t have a lot of experience setting fields and the like.But on to your article, which I thought was great. Perhaps in a Samsonesque moment Rick(y) gained captaincy nous when his hair re-appeared. Yeah Yeah.The thought of Marto sleeping with Durka-Dar is a scary one, especially considering how hot his missus is. Still, it’s a very valid explanation for Aleem giving him out twice bbw (bat before wicket).You were perving on Rianna Ponting? Give yourself an uppercut.

  2. Uncle J rod says:

    I would like to point out that my view was from behind Mrs Ponting. When you say annointed next captain, im assuming you meant to asterisk that with if cameron white isn’t a regular in the side by then.

  3. Andrew Mosey says:

    Cameron White couldn’t possibly be captain.. HE’S A FREAKING VICTORIAN!He’d only make it in under a quota system and only evil countries implement them.

  4. Andrew Mosey says:

    and I’m not convinced that the ‘I was behind her’ excuse will save you this time Uncle J..http://www.theage.com.au/news/news/one-of-my-greatest-years-ponting/2007/02/05/1170524028996.html

  5. Uncle J rod says:

    If David Hussey is elected as PM, the quota system will be implemented. Evil or not.

  6. Andrew Mosey says:

    I’d vote for David Hussey as PM.. but then again he’s not a Victorian either.

  7. Ashu says:

    Ponting s real test as captain would come now with the 3 of his greatest allies gone and a couple of more in Gilly and Haydo lined up to go in couple of years time. The mass exodus would really tell how good a captain Ponting is.

  8. Q says:

    Good assessment Uncle J.As I mentioned in my blog on greatest captains on well pitched – Ponting’s test as a captain starts now after the retirement of Warne and McGrath.I have never rated him as a great captain cause he inherited a champion team from Waugh and as u mentioned, he never had to work on it.His test will continue next season or thereafter as Hayden and Gilchrist move on as well.

  9. sportsfreak says:

    His captaincy record until now has been rubbish; most obvious in the strange (gay?) refusal to enforce the follow-on. Also, the decision to bowl after McGrath trod on the ball in Brummie was a bit … Tasmanian.I was at the Basin in 2005 where he kept on batting and batting fully in the knowledge that rain was around. The match ended as a draw, with Australia probably about 2 hours away from winning it.I’d say the loss of the old hands will be the best thing for him; if only he could shake that Dubya likeness…

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 9,049 other followers